Public housing blocks in Tin Shui Wai

A City Formerly Known as Sadness – Tin Shui Wai

Jump to the
comments ↓

Author Mika Savela

SummaryMika Savela looks at the fate of a large scale suburban housing complex in Hong Kong.

Themes Myths of Modernism

Content Case Study
FA Perspectives

Date2 July 2013

Share this article



In the early years of the 1990s, a vast new town started to rise up in the North-Western corner of the New Territories region in Hong Kong. As if out of nowhere, the towering suburb of Tin Shui Wai (天水圍) – literally signifying a place enclosed by heaven and water – was born on reclaimed land. The 270,000 people neighborhood was equal in scale to most smaller western cities – telling of the size of Hong Kong’s decades-long public housing scheme. The project, however, was to become a failure on several accounts, and due to its scale the consequences were equally devastating.

Public housing blocks in Tin Shui WaiPublic housing blocks in Tin Shui Wai

Many of the inhabitants in the cramped public housing were new immigrants from mainland China, often unemployed and unaccustomed to urban life. Situated far away from central areas, without jobs, activities or services, Tin Shui Wai quickly began to eerily resemble text book examples of bad suburban planning from the worst days of modernism. By the early 2000s, Hong Kongers had become faced with a series of suicides and family tragedies taking place in the district. Tin Shui Wai’s reputation as a “city of sadness” was cemented by the Hong Kong cinema, with several depictions of the shocking incidents as well as immigrants’ hardships and everyday resilience.

Laundry drying on the bridge railingLaundry drying on the bridge railing

Seen today from afar the extremely tall and monotonous apartment blocks seem to form a unified barrier, adding to the image of a city in isolation. But reaching Tin Shui Wai on the ground level tells a more human story. Elderly people and children fill the streets, while parents stay at work late into the evening, far away in the commercial districts of Hong Kong. Unemployment and poverty persist, but people keep quietly getting by and the area appears almost sleepy and rural, bordered by a river flowing down to Shenzhen Bay, surrounded with wetlands and old village settlements. Residents dry their laundry on the bridges, and some still take out their birdcages to the park – an old practice now practically disappeared in most modernized urban areas.

The quiet riverThe quiet river

The government, in response to the area’s reputation, has slowly kept updating public services in the area and adding resources dealing with the social issues. Across the river, a new development is being planned. With booming Shenzhen just across the water and with hopefully some accumulated wisdom in building new towns, who knows what lies in the future for the former city of sadness.

Mika Savela is an architect currently based in Hong Kong. His PhD research, at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, deals with new urban China and architectural curatorial practice. 

You might also be interested in:
A City Formerly Known as Sadness – Tin Shui Wai

Author Mika Savela

SummaryMika Savela looks at the fate of a large scale suburban housing complex in Hong Kong.

Themes Myths of Modernism

Content Case Study
FA Perspectives

Date2 July 2013

Share this article
3 comments on this article

Lyn

03 / 07 / 2013 21:08

misia

29 / 10 / 2013 04:45

Mika Savela

29 / 10 / 2013 06:03

Join the discussion:

This is a preview of FA 2014.1.
For the live version log out of Wordpress,
or open FA in an incognito/private window.